"Eisenhower was president,
Senator
Joe was king;
Long as you didn't say nothing,
you
could say anything."
From
the song: Julius and Ethel,
Bob Dylan, 1983 |
PLAYERS 1 |
rosenbergtrial.org
NCRRC
113 University Place
8th Floor
New York, NY 10003
212 / 228 4500
mail@rosenbergtrial.org |
target
DEFENDANTS
Julius Rosenberg:
Julius
Rosenberg, the son of Jewish Polish immigrants, was born on May 12, 1918
in New York City. As a boy, Julius attended a religious school in
lower Manhattan. His father hoped that he would become a rabbi, but Julius
enrolled at the City College of New York to study electrical engineering.
Many college students in the 1930's were concerned about the economic chaos
of the depression. Strikes and violence, loss of homes and jobs, were indicators
that the political and economic system was
going bankrupt. And overseas fascism was a growing threat. So it was not
unusual that some of the best minds and most caring people of that time
pursued an interest in politics by joining socialist or communist
organizations.
Julius joined the Steinmetz Club, the campus branch of the Young Communist
League. There he would meet Morton Sobell. The summer after Julius graduated
in 1939, he married Ethel Greenglass. They both became members of the American
Communist
Party.
After almost a year of doing freelance work (until the fall of 1940), Julius
was hired as a civilian employee of the U.S. Army Signal Corps. In 1942
he was promoted to the position of inspector. By 1943, the
Rosenbergs were not active in the Communist Party.
Early in 1945, when his past membership in the Communist Party came to
light, Julius was fired from his job with the Signal Corps. He took a job
with the Emerson Radio Corporation for awhile; and then in 1946 formed
G & R Engineering Company with his brother-in-laws Bernard and David
Greenglass, and Isadore Goldstein. [partnership disbanded]
Julius lived with his wife and two children
(from 1942) in a three room apartment near the waterfront in Manhattan's
lower East Side.
On June 17, 1950, based upon David Greenglass' statements to the FBI, Julius
Rosenberg was arrested on suspicion of espionage. He was tried (March 6,
1951) on the charge of conspiring to commit espionage; and after
a guilty verdict (March 29, 1951) was sentence to death. The appeal process
lasted over two years while Julius was on death row. Here he maintained
his innocence and hoped for leniency. It was during these years that the
case aroused the attention of the international community.
Julius Rosenberg was put to death in the electric chair at Sing-Sing Prison
in New York on June 19, 1953.
". . . I am not much at
saying good-byes because I believe that good accomplishments live on forever
but this I can say - my love of life has never been so strong because I've
seen how beautiful the future can be. . . For peace, bread and roses
in simple dignity we face the executioner with courage, confidence and
perspective - never losing faith.
P.S. All my personal effects are in
3 cartons and you can get them from the Warden.
All my love - Julie"
From Julius' final letter to his attorney and friend Emanuel Bloch. |
target
Ethel Rosenberg:
Ethel
Greenglass Rosenberg, the only daughter of Barnet and Tessie Greenglass
was born September 28, 1915 in New York City. The family was poor
and they lived in a crowded, shabby unheated tenement apartment
on the lower East side of Manhattan. Ethel attended a religious school,
then high school and graduated at the age of only 15.
Almost immediately after finishing school, Ethel became a clerk for a shipping
company. Here she was confronted with poor working
conditions and low salaries. But instead of accepting her plight and that
of her fellow workers, she decided to speak out and to organize. Four years
later she was fired because of her role as the organizer of a strike of
150 women workers. Labor issues and politics were combined when Ethel joined
the Young Communist League and eventually became a member of the American
Communist Party.
Besides being an activist, Ethel enjoyed singing, and had aspirations of
becoming an opera singer. She was waiting to go on stage to sing at a New
Years Eve benefit when she first met Julius Rosenberg. The couple were
soon married in the summer of 1939.
Although still interested in politics, most of her time and energy were
spent at home caring for her two sons Michael and Robert. In 1943 she left
the Communist Party and a few years later was helping her husband in the
business with her brother David Greenglass.
During the spring of 1950 David Greenglass, named Julius Rosenberg as a
participant in the spy ring. This led to the arrest of her husband on June
17. Almost two months later on August 11, 1950, Ethel Rosenberg was herself
arrested and charged with conspiracy to commit espionage. On April
5, 1951 after a guilty verdict, she was sentenced to death. The next two
years of Ethel Rosenberg's life were spent on death row at Sing Sing prison.
Here she maintained her innocence and hoped for leniency.
Ethel Rosenberg was put to death in the electric chair at Sing- Sing prison
in New York on June 19, 1953.
". . . We wish we might have had the
tremendous joy and gratification of living our lives out with you. Your
Daddy who is with me in the last momentous hours, sends his heart and all
the love that is in it for his dearest boys. Always remember that we were
innocent and could not wrong our conscience.
We press you closes and kiss you with
all our strength.
Lovingly
Daddy and Mommy"
From Ethel's final letter to her sons. |
target
Morton Sobell: Morton
Sobell and Julius Rosenberg were students attending CCNY studying
engineering. Here they became friends and both, for a short time, were
members of the Young Communist League. (Morton and his wife Helen have
stated that they had never belonged to the Communist Party.) Also at CCNY,
Morton became good friends with Max Elitcher, a Stuyvesant High School
classmate. After graduation (with
a degree in electrical engineering) Max and Morton shared an apartment
in Washington D.C. where they worked for the Navy Bureau of Ordnance.
In 1941 Morton left Washington but still kept in contact with Elitcher.
It was in 1943 that Max, who was recently married, took his new wife to
Schenectady to meet Morton. Morton at the time was working for General
Electric. Two years later Elitcher was best man at Sobell's wedding.
Several years later both Max and Morton were living in Flushing, Queens,
New York and both working for the Reeves Instrument Company. In June of
1950 Morton, his wife Helen and their two children left on a trip to Mexico.
While living in an apartment in Mexico City, Morton learns of the arrest
of Julius Rosenberg. He then considers trying to find passage for himself
and his family from Mexico, but without the proper documents was unable
to do so. In the middle of August the Sobells were kidnapped by
Mexican thugs and delivered to U. S. authorities at the border where the
FBI arrested him for conspiring with Julius Rosenberg to violate the espionage
laws.
The trial
began March 6, 1951. Max Elitcher, the government's only witness, testified
against his friend Morton Sobell. And as with the Rosenbergs, the jury
delivered a guilty verdict. Morton Sobell was sentenced to 30 years in
prison, five of which he served in Alcatraz. He was finally released from
prison in 1969. His autobiography, On Doing Time, details his experiences
in jail and presents his view of events before, during and after the Rosenberg
trial. Morton Sobell is currently involved as a civil liberty activist
and maintains his innocence to this day.
target
PROSECUTORS
Herbert Brownell:
Herbert
Brownell, born in Peru, Nebraska in 1904, started began his career as a
lawyer in New York City in 1927. Except for the years 1953 to 1957, when
he was the Attorney General under President Eisenhower, he continued
in private practice as a lawyer up to his retirement in 1989.
Mr.
Brownell became active in New York State politics and served in
the state legislature (1933 - 1937). He managed Thomas E. Dewey’s successful
campaign for the New York governorship (1942) as well as Dewey’s unsuccessful
presidential bids (1944, 1948). From 1944 to 1946 he chaired the Republican
National Committee and was instrumental in getting Dwight D. Eisenhower
to run for office (1951). Bownell was named Attorney General and functioned
as a close adviser to the president, wielding considerable influence over
many of the president's decisions.
These decisions included the presidents denial of clemency for the Rosenbergs.
Was Brownell also influential in having the President believe that the
Supreme Court reviewed the Rosenberg case? Did he play a part in keeping
the President uninformed about the extent of world opinion regarding this
case?
According to journalist Robert Donovan and Presidential speech writer Emmet
John Hughs, both of whom were present at various meetings between President
Eisenhower and Brownell, the Attorney General told Eisenhower that Douglas's
stay was "without foundation". Brownell also added that "information
which corroborated the guilt of the Rosenbergs was in possession of the
government. . . . but could not have been used at the trial." Brownell
had no such evidence.
Perhaps the most flagrant misuse of the office of Attorney General occurred
during the week of June 15, 1953. During a meeting
brokered by Justice Jackson, Brownell met with Chief Justice Vinson.
This ex parte type of communication was highly improper and violated
many canons of judicial conduct. FBI memoranda state that it was
during this meeting that the contingency plan of a special court
session was to happen if one of the Justices
delivered a stay of execution.
Brownell's rush to execute the Rosenbergs was not to be slowed down. Since
the Supreme Court's special session pushed the execution to Friday at 11:00
pm, the defense asked for a delay (to Saturday night) because Friday sundown
starts the Jewish sabbath. Herbert J. Brownell now had his chance to extend
his maliciousness to a new height: he
scheduled the executions earlier that day at 8:00 pm.
In 1957 he resigned his position as U. S. Attorney General and returned
to his New York law practice. He died in 1996.
target
Irving Saypol:
Irving
Saypol was the United States Attorney for the Southern District of New
York and the Chief Prosecutor of the Julius and Ethel Rosenberg and Morton
Sobell. Saypol graduated from Brooklyn Law School and quickly rose through
the ranks of the United States
Attorney's office. Saypol was an experienced prosecutor of Communists,
as he had convicted Alger Hiss, William Remington, Abraham Brothman and
others prior to taking on the Rosenberg case. Part of his success was attributable
to his sincere belief that he was punishing evil. Some of his critics charge
that Saypol, who warmed to his task at prosecuting the Rosenbergs, blurred
any distinction between the crime charged - conspiracy to commit espionage
- and treason. His success in the Rosenberg trial accelerated his career.
Saypol was appointed to the New York Supreme Court just months after the
trial.
target
Roy Cohn: Roy
Cohn was the son of Judge Albert Cohn of the New York State Supreme Court,
joined the U.S. Attorney's office following law school. He became one of
Irving Saypol's assistants on the Rosenberg prosecution team (Cohn had
worked with Saypol prior to the Rosenberg case in an trial of eleven Communists).
In Cohn's autobiography (The Autobiography of Roy Cohn, co-aurthored
by Sidney Zion) he reveals his collusion with Judge Irving Kaufman before,
during and after the Rosenberg trial. He even reveals his frame-up technique
(page 160): ". . . as a young assistant U.S. attorney, I convicted my
share of people on uncorroborated accomplice testimony." He describes
how the U.S. Attorney offers a deal to a guilty defendant, if he/she agrees
to name as an accomplice the person the prosecutor wishes to frame. The
jury convicts both, the framed victim is heavily sentenced, while the actual
criminal receives a minor sentence.
During the trial, Cohn was noticed by Senator Joseph McCarthy and
later served as his aide. Senator McCarthy, became infamous for his accusations
of Communist infiltration of the State Department and other high government
posts. Cohn provided legal guidance to the Senator in his Communist "witch-hunt"
which would become known as "McCarthyism." Eventually Senator McCarthy's
influence declined and he, along with Cohn, was discredited.
From 1954 to 1986, he became a political power broker and
much-sought legal talent with Saxe, Bacon
& Bolan (and predecessor firms) in New York City. Known as a loyal
advocate, he gave lavish annual parties for his famous, fashionable clients
and friends at his Greenwich, Conn., estate. Thrice tried and acquitted
on federal charges of conspiracy, bribery, and fraud, he was disbarred
two months before his death from AIDS in 1986. He admired dogs and had
an extensive collection of stuffed animals.
target
WITNESSES
David Greenglass:
David
Greenglass, known as "Doovey" to his older sister Ethel Greenglass Rosenberg,
was born in 1922. A machinist who had learned his trade at Manhattan's
Haaren Aviation High School, he was married Ruth Prinz at the age of twenty
and shortly after was inducted into the Army. He was stationed in Oak Ridge,
Tennessee and then later in the Manhattan Project in Los Alamos, New Mexico.
In late November 1944, David got a few days leave to see his wife, Ruth
in Albuquerque on their second wedding anniversary. It was from her at
this time that he he allegedly learned the nature of the secret project
at Los Alamos. "She told me that Julius has said that I was working
on the atom bomb." [NCRRC: if the Manhattan Project was a secret, and
it
was top secret, how did Julius at the end of 1944 know about it.]
It was when David was on furlough in January of 1945 that he prepared some
sketches and a written description of lens mold experiments that he gave
to Julius. Ruth mentioned "that David's handwriting would be bad . .
. and Julius said . . . Ethel would type it up." [NCRRC: David was
a draftsman and his handwriting was extremely legible.]
When his leave ended, David returned to Los Alamos. Several Months later,
Ruth followed him to New Mexico and rented an apartment in Albuquerque,
where David spent weekends. It was in June of 1945 that the supposed exchange
involving Jello boxes, money and passwords took place.
In September of 1945 David was again on leave and supposedly he and Ruth
bought material to the Rosenbergs for filming and typing in their living
room. [NCRRC: David Greenglass admitted he lied about this meeting on 60
Minutes II, December 5, 2001.]
After his army discharged, David joined
his brother Bernard and Julius in a machine shop business. The business
did last long and the partnership broke up; not all that amicably.
Shortly
after Klaus Fuchs was arrested in England, David and Ruth Greenglass were
interrogated by the FBI arrested in the United States. Greenglass under
the threat of a long prison sentence and possibly a death sentence, decided
to be a prosecution witness against his sister and his brother-in-law.
He did this because in exchange for immunity for his wife Ruth, so that
she might remain with their two children; and a light sentence for himself.
To his surpass he received a 15 year sentence. He served only 10 years
and remained together with with Ruth when he was released in 1960.
Even though the Greenglasses changed their name and address, they were
found in 1987 by Sam Roberts of the New York Times. David was living
under an assumed name in a single-family house in the Queens, New York.
After fourteen years, for monetary reasons alone, he decided to be interviewed
by Roberts. These interviews resulted in the book The Brother,
published in the fall of 2001. In this book Greenglass admits that he lied
on the witness stand. "My wife is my wife. I mean, I don't sleep with
my sister, you know." From David Greenglass's point of view,
such fidelity was commendable.
Further admission of perjury came on 60
Minutes II, December 5, 2001. It was this perjury that strapped his
sister Ethel into the electric chair. According to Roberts, Greenglass,
when asked if he would have done anything differently, replied "Never.
"And when asked on 60
Minutes, why didn't the Rosenbergs talk (lie) and give names like he
did, he said
"In one word - stupidity."
target
Ruth Greenglass:
Ruth
Printz, born in 1925, grew up in the same New York City neighborhood as
her future husband, David Greenglass. In late November 1942, Ruth married
David Greenglass in November , 1942 before he was drafted. Both Ruth and
David had an interest in politics and together they joined the Young Communist
League.
The couple had not been married long before David was drafted in 1943.
He was eventually stationed at Los Alamos working as a machinist on the
Manhattan Project. The two had always been a close couple and Ruth tried
to see David as much as possible. To do this they rented a house in nearby
Albuquerque, where David would spend weekends.
At the end of the war Ruth and David moved back to New York City
and became parents. From 1946 to 1950 Ruth had two miscarriages and had
a near fatal accident. Most of her time was spent caring for her children.
When the FBI questioned David Greenglass in 1950 about suspected espionage
activities, he agreed to confess and to be a witness against Julius and
Ethel Rosenberg. This was done in exchange for immunity for Ruth so that
she could remain at home with their two children. The FBI threatened the
couple with imprisonment and even death. (Even though the FBI claim that
she was never arrested, there does exists a mug
shot of Ruth.) And while in custody during the seven months before
the trial, they changed their story with regard to the Rosenbergs.
Ruth eventually testified against the Rosenbergs at trial stating that
Ethel Rosenberg had typed up the notes that David Greenglass had provided,
implicating Ethel in the espionage ring. FBI documents and later admission
by her husband indicate that this was perjured testimony. And was her testimony
that it was Julius and Ethel who urged her to convince David Greenglass
to become involved is espionage also perjury? Ruth Greenglass , a confessed
spy, was never even indicted. She rejoined with her husband after his release
from prison, changed her name and sought anonymity.
target
Harry Gold: Harry
Gold was the son of poor Russian Jewish immigrants. He was a small quiet
boy abused by his schoolmates. As a young man both he and his family became
interested in Socialism, which probably led him to make contacts within
the Communist movement.
In 1935, Gold, a nondescript chemist working
for a sugar company, decided to act on his Communist sympathies by stealing
industrial secrets from his factory and passing them on to the Soviets.
As Gold escalated his espionage activities he began to tell his various
contacts elaborate tales of his family life. But Gold's tales were all
fantasy, he was actually a bachelor. He was an inveterate liar. (His own
attorney John Hamilton disclosed that his client sometimes supplied
the
Soviets fictitious names and delivered fabricated reports about these nonexistent
contacts.) Gold also began drinking heavily and was sloppy with the evidence
of his illegal activities. Perhaps he wanted to be caught.
Gold, after given several days warning that the FBI were going to search
his home (without a warrant), did not get rid of any incriminating evidence.
Was Gold mentally tired of continuing with deceit and intrigue? And why
did the FBI allow Gold to get rid of any evidence in his home? Even more
mysterious is the Gold-Fuchs connection. Fuchs never identified Gold as
his contact. The physical description of the courier that Fuchs is said
to have used definitely did not fit Harry Gold. Gold had the ability to
perpetrate fantastic deceptions and lies. His statements regarding people,
places, dates, meetings, conversations are later denied or altered.
When the FBI caught up with him, he surrendered meekly, "confessed" and
was sentenced to 30 years in prison. He then offered to be a witness for
the government in the Rosenberg trial.
He often readily agreed to change his testimony to suit the FBI. "I come
from Ben from Brooklyn" becomes "I come from Julius." "Information from
Greenglass was of no value" to it was "extremely excellent and very valuable."
Even Gold's connection with Anatoli Yakovlev, the absent co-defendant,
is suspect. Many personal details (given at pre-trial hearing) about Yakovlev,
later proved to be false.
Gold
later admitted that during pre-trial hearings he could not recall Greenglass's
name. That he had "completely forgotten" his meeting with Yakovlev in New
York; his visit to David Greenglass in New Mexico; and the password
"I
come from Julius." Needless to say the FBI helped him to
remember these details.
Other inconsistencies are Gold's registering at the Albuquerque Hilton
under his own name; and possibly forged registration cards with wrong dates.
And if Gold, as a courier picked up classified material from Fuchs, why
would he then, on the same trip, stop at the Greenglass's? This goes against
any type of espionage protocol.
Unfortunately Harry Gold was not cross-examined by Bloch. Thus, the truth
behind Harry Gold's testimony lies buried in the files of the FBI and in
a Philadelphia cemetery; he died August 28, 1972, seven years after he
was released from prison.
target
Max Elitcher: Elitcher
and Sobell became friends while attending Stuyvesant High School together.
Later, between 1934 and 1938 they both attended the College of the City
of New York where they both
studied electrical engineering. It was during this time that the two men
met Julius Rosenberg. Following graduation, Elitcher and Sobell moved to
Washington DC to become junior engineers at the Navy Bureau of Ordinance.
The two remained close friends and even shared an apartment together. In
1941 Morton left Washington but still kept in contact with Elitcher. It
was in 1943 that Max, who was recently married, took his new wife to Schenectady
to meet Morton. Morton at the time was working for General Electric. Two
years later Elitcher was best man at Sobell's wedding.
In 1948, Elitcher left government
service to take a job at Reeves Instrument. Elitcher and his wife moved
into a house in Queens, New York. Their backyard neighbors were the Sobells.
Elitcher maintained that
Julius Rosenberg had attempted to recruit him as a spy during the years
1944 -1948. Elitcher then testified that in the summer of 1948, he accompanied
Sobell to Catherine Slip in Manhattan, where he was to deliver something
(it seemed to be a 35 millimeter film can) to Julius Rosenberg. Sobell
left the car briefly with the film can; Elitcher never saw the person who
received it. His testimony, which required continual prompting by prosecuting
attorney Saypol, raised objections from the defense. When Elitcher repeated
parts of his testimony there were changes and omissions.
Furthermore, Elitcher admitted
that he lied on a federal Loyalty Oath form in 1947 and was extremely fearful
of being charged with perjury. This he stated was a factor in becoming
a witness for the prosecution.
Although Elitcher
shared many of Rosenberg's and Sobell's political beliefs, he claimed to
have never passed secret information to either. And he never met the Greenglasses
and was never indicted for perjury.
target
THE
SUPREME COURT: The Roosevelt-Truman
Supreme Court was in place from the time of the Rosenberg's arrest to their
executions. During those 28 months the Supreme Court never reviewed
the Rosenberg case. That a case of type, with so many controvertible
issues, was never examined by the court displays the highest form
of judicial insolence. Politicization and internecine squabbles contaminated
the judicial process.
top of page
|